Verification · 驗證政策

數字由自動閘負責,唔靠人手核對

Numbers are checked by automated gates, not by hand

呢一頁係本站嘅硬規矩:唔會要求營運者逐項人手核對數字,亦唔會用「我睇過」當成保證。 每一類對外數字都要有一支可以重推嘅自動檢查;冇自動檢查嘅資料,就唔會當成統計數字發布。

四條原則

  1. 每一個對外數字、序列同名單,都要有一支自動閘可以重推:生成檔必須同已登記來源一致,唔一致即紅。

    Every published figure, series and list has an automated gate that can re-derive it: a generated file must match its registered source, or the build fails.

  2. 營運者唔需要、亦唔會被要求逐項人手核對。人手只負責選來源、寫背景同判斷範圍;數字對錯由閘負責。

    The operator is never asked to check items by hand. Humans choose sources, write background and judge scope; the gates are responsible for whether the numbers match.

  3. 官方只有 PDF/新聞稿、冇機器可讀版本嘅資料,唔會當成統計數字發布;只會寫入「已知缺口」,並講明未收錄。

    Where an official source exists only as a PDF or press release with no machine-readable version, it is not published as a statistic; it is recorded as a known gap instead.

  4. 編輯文字(背景、解讀、限制)同數字分開:改文字唔會改到任何數字;數字只可以經來源登記同生成器更新。

    Editorial prose (background, interpretation, limitations) is kept apart from figures: editing prose cannot change a number, and numbers only change through registered sources and generators.

逐層自動檢查(22 類/26 支指令)

下表每一層都係實際跑得嘅指令;任何一項失敗,建置就唔會通過。指令只喺「機器版」顯示, 人讀版唔會見到建置細節。

層檢查啲咩指令
數字來源登記
Figures and sources
每個數字都要有已登記來源同 asOf;每條數字有自己嘅永久網址,來源對唔上即紅。
Every figure must carry a registered source and a reference date; each has its own permanent URL, and a missing source fails the gate.
npm run audit:sources
npm run audit:fact-routes
官方統計角度
Official statistics angles
登記冊、官方 API 快取同生成檔三邊逐字對比;每個角度只准一條年度序列。
The registry, the cached official API response and the generated file are compared verbatim; each angle is exactly one annual series.
npm run audit:official-stats
時間序列結構
Time series structure
每條序列都有來源、抓取時間同點算規則;年度值只可由官方月度/逐日數據按寫明嘅規則匯總。
Each series carries its source, fetch time and aggregation rule; annual values may only be derived from official monthly or daily data under the stated rule.
npm run check:series
數據新鮮度
Data freshness
每條數字按官方發布頻率計齡;超過容許上限即標示「可能已過期」並令檢查失敗。
Every figure is aged against its official publication cadence; anything beyond the tolerance is flagged as possibly stale and fails the check.
npm run audit:data-freshness
口徑對照
Measurement bases
同名數字有兩套官方口徑時,逐組講明邊個唔可以同邊個相加/互換;口徑層唔准出現手寫數字。
Where one name has two official bases, each group states what may not be added or interchanged; the calibre layer may not contain hand-written numbers.
npm run audit:calibres
核心資料結構
Core schema
id/key 唯一、無簡體字漏入正文、文章註記同來源仍然對得上。
IDs and keys are unique, no simplified characters leak into copy, and article notes still match their registered sources.
node scripts/audit-core-schema.mjs
地圖幾何
Map geometry
十八區地圖由官方邊界 cache 簡化生成;同 cache 逐字對比,唔准手改。
The district map is generated by simplifying the official boundary cache; it must match the cache byte for byte.
npm run check:district-map
交通時間軸
Transport timeline
時間軸只由志錄已核交通條目派生;條目數、時期、錨點同連結由志錄獨立重算。
The timeline is derived only from verified transport entries in the chronicle; counts, periods, anchors and links are re-derived independently.
npm run audit:transport-timeline
文學志錄層
Literature chronicle layer
文學頁只由志錄已核條目派生;條目數、時期、文類關鍵詞同頁面錨點由志錄獨立重算,並擋「本站自行排名」。
Literature pages are derived only from verified chronicle entries; counts, periods, genre keywords and page anchors are re-derived independently, and self-ranking is rejected.
npm run audit:literature
公共屋邨名錄
Public housing estate register
屋邨名錄只由房屋委員會開放數據派生;生成檔同快取逐字比對、每條有官方欄位,冇機讀名錄嘅居屋只列缺口。
The estate register is derived only from Housing Authority open data; the generated file is compared verbatim with the cache, every row carries official fields, and HOS courts (no machine-readable list) are recorded as gaps.
npm run check:housing-estate-directory
公眾泳池名錄
Public swimming pool register
泳池名錄只由康文署開放數據派生;生成檔同快取逐字比對,官方最後更新日照實顯示,唔會自行寫開放時間。
The pool register is derived only from LCSD open data; the generated file is compared verbatim with the cache, the official last-update date is shown, and opening hours are never invented.
npm run check:swimming-pools
燒烤場名錄
Barbecue site register
燒烤場名錄只由漁護署同康文署開放數據派生;生成檔同快取逐字比對,唔會自行寫「今日開唔開」。
The barbecue register is derived only from AFCD and LCSD open data; the generated file is compared verbatim with the cache, and the site never reports whether a venue is open today.
npm run check:barbecue-sites
CSDI 名錄(建築/遠足/管制站)
CSDI registers (graded buildings / trails / control points)
三份名錄只由 CSDI 官方圖層派生;生成檔同快取逐字比對、id 唯一、接線同頁面 anchor 全部重推。
Three registers are derived only from official CSDI layers; generated files are compared verbatim with caches, ids are unique, and wiring plus page anchors are re-derived.
npm run check:graded-buildings
npm run check:hiking-trails
npm run check:control-points
戶外名錄(泳灘/露營地)
Outdoor registers (beaches / campsites)
泳灘同露營地名錄只由官方開放數據派生;生成檔同快取逐字比對,水質只抄本週公布、營位數目照官方。
Beach and campsite registers are derived from official open data only; generated files are compared verbatim with caches, water quality copies the weekly publication, and tent spaces follow the official CSV.
npm run check:beaches
npm run check:campsites
公共交通路線清冊
Public transport route register
路線清冊只由運輸署官方 XML 派生;生成檔同快取逐字比對,官方資料修正截止日同逐條「官方最後更新日」照實顯示,官方代碼欄位只照印原字(冇機讀代碼表),班次同到站時間一律唔會出現。
The route register is derived only from the Transport Department XML files; the generated file is compared verbatim with the cache, the official data revision cut-off and each route’s official last-update date are shown as published, official code fields are printed verbatim (no machine-readable code table), and frequencies or arrival times never appear.
npm run check:transport-routes
十八區分佈指標
District distribution metrics
/districts 熱力表同填色地圖共用一份分區計數;每個指標都要可以由官方名錄獨立重推,重推唔到區份嘅條目要照實報數(唔准靜靜漏),頁面填色圖數要等於指標數。
The district heatmap table and choropleth maps share one set of district counts; every metric must be independently re-derivable from the official registers, rows whose district cannot be derived are reported rather than dropped silently, and the number of choropleth maps must equal the number of metrics.
npm run audit:district-metrics
薄頁分層
Thin-page tiers
獨有內容不足嘅頁唔會主動提交 sitemap;薄頁名單要有記錄同理由。
Pages without enough unique content are not submitted in the sitemap; the thin list must carry a recorded reason.
npm run audit:thin
Sitemap 完整性
Sitemap integrity
每個可索引頁都要出現,冇多餘 URL、冇未來日期、冇重複 loc。
Every indexable page appears, with no extra URLs, no future dates and no duplicate locations.
npm run audit:sitemap
頁面洩漏
Rendered-output leaks
逐頁掃渲染出嚟嘅文字同 JSON-LD,唔准漏出內部值(例如未定義欄位、非數字值、或者物件被直接內插)或 Markdown 殘留。
Rendered text and JSON-LD are scanned page by page; internal placeholders, non-numeric values, directly interpolated objects and leftover Markdown are not allowed.
npm run audit:html-leaks
結構化資料
Structured data
每個 Dataset 都要有 name/description/creator,數值要包成 PropertyValue,日期要符合 ISO 8601。
Every Dataset needs a name, description and creator; values must be wrapped as PropertyValue and dates must be ISO 8601.
npm run audit:structured-data
機器出口
Machine endpoints
端點登記冊、OpenAPI 同各出口一致;機器出口唔准漏內部值(未定義欄位、非數字值或物件)。
The endpoint registry, OpenAPI document and every machine surface agree; machine surfaces must not leak internal values.
npm run audit:ai-endpoints

唔會派人手核對工作

  • 任何數字、序列、名單、年份:一律由自動閘重推。本站唔會要求營運者逐條核對, 亦唔會用「已人手核對」當成保證。
  • 需要人手核讀嘅層已凍結(古籍掃描本內容、人物傳記):唔再新增條目; 現有條目維持標明「人手核讀」同 provenance,唔會擴張。
  • 未自動核實嘅嘢就係缺口:例如天星小輪 1888 年成立/1898 年改組年份, 官方一手網上來源對唔上,本站維持留空,唔會靠人手補、亦唔會靠推定補。

咩嘢唔會當統計數字發布

  • 官方只有 PDF/新聞稿、冇機器可讀版本嘅資料:唔會抄成一個數,只會寫入已知缺口,講明未收錄同原因。
  • 估算同策展數字(例如「建議停留幾多分鐘」):一律唔收;站規係每個數字要有sourceId 同 asOf。
  • 外部開放資料層(例如 OSM/Wikidata 場地座標):會清楚標明「未經官方核實」, 而且唔會混入官方統計數字。
  • 編輯文字(背景、解讀、限制):同數字分開;改文字唔會改到任何數字。

呢頁唔會證明啲咩

自動閘只證明「同一份輸入會得出同一結果」,唔證明資料來源本身無誤;亦唔會令本站變成官方機構。 官方數字仍然以部門公布為準,本站只負責照錄同標明出處。

你唔同意嘅話可以點做

覺得某個數字或者某句判斷有問題,請用頁尾聯絡方法提出,並附上官方出處; 一經核實會記入 覆蓋範圍(包括影響範圍同修正日期),唔會靜靜改咗就算。

更新方式

檢查清單同數字由自動工作更新,唔靠人手逐項核對;官方一改,下一次抓取就會反映,並會經 sitemap 嘅 lastmod 顯示。 呢一頁嘅說明文字唔會跟數字一齊自動改 —— 文字改動要人手寫,避免「機器自己講自己準」。

呢一頁同其他頁嘅分工

數字本身喺各自嘅名錄/年表頁(例如交通、歷史建築、遠足徑);呢一頁只講「點保證數字唔會亂」。 出錯嘅紀錄集中記喺 覆蓋範圍,唔會四散。

你可以自己核對

  • /api/v1/gaps.json:本站刻意唔會當統計數字發布嘅資料(逐項原因同官方入口)。
  • /api/v1/series.json:全部序列、來源、抓取日同計算規則(可用 ?id=、?from=、?to=)。
  • 每條序列嘅 CSV:/data/series/<id>.csv,檔頭列明來源同規則。
  • 點樣讀走勢:指數同金額、名義同實質、基期、年均同年底嘅讀法。
  • 志錄點用:條目編號、頁碼、原文時間標籤同引用錨點。
  • 路線清冊點用:官方代碼、車費同時點嘅讀法。
  • 法定古蹟點查:宣布年份、位置同評級嘅用法。
  • 已評級建築點查:一級/二級/三級嘅範圍同限制。
  • 引用本站資料:引用格式、要附咩資料、常見錯誤。
  • /api/v1/index.json:端點總覽同部署版本(build.sha)。
  • /openapi.json:OpenAPI 3.1,可直接註冊工具。
  • /coverage:收咗咩、未收咩、每層嘅自動檢查結果。
  • /licence:結構化資料授權同範圍。

相關頁面:關於本站、覆蓋範圍、口徑對照。

↑