電影 · Film · 2016
樹大招風
Trivisa
| 作品 / Work | 樹大招風 Trivisa |
|---|---|
| 年份 / Year | 2016 |
| 媒介 / Medium | 電影 Film |
| 判定 / Verdict | 部分準確 Partly accurate |
坊間流傳嘅橋段 / The claim
「三大賊王張子強、葉繼歡、季炳雄真係互相認識、夾埋做一單大案?」
Did the three 'kings of thieves' — Cheung Tze-keung, Yip Kai-foon and Kwai Ping-hung — really know one another and plot a joint mega-heist?
事實應該係點 / What really happens
電影讓三名賊王卓子強、葉國歡、季正雄在1997年同一酒樓出現,江湖盛傳三人聯手。三人原型為張子強、葉繼歡、季炳雄,現實中三方從未合作。據南華早報及內地報道,張子強只與葉繼歡合謀,1996年5月在港綁架李嘉誠長子李澤鉅,勒索逾十億元;季炳雄自成一路,其持械拒捕發生於2001年5月22日旺角,打傷兩名警員,並非電影的1997年。三人下場各異:張子強1998年在內地經終審判處死刑並處決;葉繼歡1996年登岸時中彈被捕、下半身癱瘓,2017年4月19日在瑪麗醫院羈留病房因肺癌病逝,終年56歲;季炳雄2003年12月在佐敦被飛虎隊拘捕,判囚24年,2020年1月刑滿後被遞解往美國。
In the film the three mobsters Cheuk Tze-keung, Yip Kwok-foon and Kwai Ching-hung turn up at the same restaurant in 1997, and the city buzzes with talk of a joint mega-heist. They are based on Cheung Tze-keung, Yip Kai-foon and Kwai Ping-hung, who in reality never worked as a trio. According to the South China Morning Post and mainland reports, Cheung plotted only with Yip, kidnapping Li Ka-shing's eldest son Victor Li in Hong Kong in May 1996 for a ransom of over HK$1 billion. Kwai operated on his own, and his armed shoot-out with police took place in Mong Kok on 22 May 2001 — not in 1997 as portrayed. Their fates differed: Cheung was executed in mainland China in 1998; Yip was shot and paralysed when arrested in 1996 and died of lung cancer in custody in 2017, aged 56; Kwai was arrested in 2003 and jailed for 24 years, then deported after his release in January 2020.
劇中不準確之處 / Inaccuracies
- 電影把三名賊王放在1997年同一酒樓出現、渲染三人聯手;現實中張子強、葉繼歡、季炳雄三方從未合作,季炳雄與二人更無共事紀錄。
- 電影把季炳雄原型角色的持械拒捕安排在1997年前後;史實是2001年5月22日在旺角發生,並打傷兩名警員。
本頁只核對劇中描述同事實嘅出入,並非對作品嘅藝術評價。判定屬編輯判斷;凡涉及法律程序嘅描述,以《基本法》、相關法例同司法機構/律政司官方資料為準。未能以官方來源核實嘅橋段一律不作判定。
同媒介其他條目 / Other Film entries
- 毒舌大狀 A Guilty Conscience(2023)部分準確
- 正義迴廊 The Sparring Partner(2022)準確
- 葉問 Ip Man(2008)不準確
- 十月圍城 Bodyguards and Assassins(2009)不準確
- 竊聽風雲 Overheard(2009)不準確
- 古惑仔之人在江湖 Young and Dangerous(1996)部分準確
資料來源 / Sources
- 「賊王」葉繼歡迫使香港警方改變戰術並加強火力 / "King of Thieves" Yip Kai-foon forced Hong Kong police to change tactics and beef up arms · 南華早報 · 2017-04-19
- 香港三大「賊王」之一葉繼歡病逝 其餘兩個「賊王」命運如何 / Yip Kai-foon, One of Hong Kong's Three "Kings of Thieves", Dies; What Became of the Other Two · 環球網 · 2017-04-19
- 張子強等非法買賣、運輸爆炸物、搶劫、綁架、走私武器彈藥上訴案(最高人民法院公報) / Cheung Tze-keung et al., appeal case on illegal trafficking of explosives, robbery, kidnapping and arms smuggling (Gazette of the Supreme People's Court) · 中華人民共和國最高人民法院
- 香港「賊王」季炳雄刑滿出獄 / Hong Kong "King of Thieves" Kwai Ping-hung Released After Completing His Sentence · 環球網