白色強人II

坊間流傳嘅橋段 / The claim

劇中一名精神病患者在行人隧道內無故亂刀斬人，精神病患者係咪真係咁有暴力傾向？

In the drama, a man with mental illness randomly slashes people with a knife in a pedestrian tunnel. Are people with mental illness really so prone to violence?

事實應該係點 / What really happens

事實是，絕大部分精神病患者及復元人士都較被動、內向，不會對陌生人施暴；有暴力傾向的只屬少數，而且部分風險與濫藥、缺乏治療等因素有關，不能簡化為「精神病等於暴力」。把精神病與隨機傷人掛鈎，會加深公眾誤解和污名化，令患者被標籤、不敢求助，阻礙康復和社區共融。香港精神科醫學院及香港社區組織協會（SoCO）先後發聲明，指該集情節引起公眾不安、對精神病患者及復元人士造成負面標籤；SoCO 更要求電視台道歉、促請平等機會委員會研究是否違反《殘疾歧視條例》，並要求通訊事務管理局按《電視通用業務守則》第 6 章《暴力》跟進。平機會指出，精神病及精神病康復者受《殘疾歧視條例》保障，不應因殘疾而遭歧視或中傷。劇集監製事後就情節引起大眾不安致歉。

In fact, the vast majority of people with mental illness, including those in recovery, are withdrawn and passive rather than violent towards strangers. Only a small minority have violent tendencies, and such risks are often linked to factors like substance misuse or lack of treatment; it is wrong to equate mental illness with violence. Linking mental illness to random knife attacks deepens public misunderstanding and stigma, discourages sufferers from seeking help, and hinders recovery and community inclusion. In Hong Kong, the Hong Kong College of Psychiatrists and the Society for Community Organization (SoCO) issued statements criticising the episode; SoCO demanded a TV apology, asked the Equal Opportunities Commission to examine whether the Disability Discrimination Ordinance was breached, and urged the Communications Authority to follow up under the code of practice on violence. Because mental illness counts as a disability under the DDO, people are protected against discrimination.

劇中不準確之處 / Inaccuracies

• 劇中把精神病患者描寫成會無故向陌生人亂刀斬人，過度渲染暴力，與現實中絕大多數患者被動內向、有暴力傾向者只屬少數不符。
• 劇情將「精神病」等同「隨機傷人」，忽略暴力風險多與缺乏治療、濫藥等臨床及社會因素相關，構成污名化。
• 劇中沒有呈現精神復元人士的真實狀況，被指對患者及復元人士不公平，加深公眾誤解。

同媒介其他條目 / Other TV series entries

• 壹號皇庭　File of Justice（1992）部分準確
• 怒火街頭　Ghetto Justice（2011）不準確
• 陀槍師姐　Armed Reaction（1998）部分準確
• 談判專家　Take My Word For It（2002）部分準確
• 法證先鋒　Forensic Heroes（2006）部分準確
• 飛虎　Tiger Cubs（2012）部分準確
• 大太監　The Confidant（2012）不準確
• 衝上雲霄II　Triumph in the Skies II（2013）不準確
• 跳躍生命線　Life on the Line（2018）部分準確
• 大時代　The Greed of Man（1992）不準確
• 使徒行者　Line Walker（2014）部分準確
• 廉政行動　ICAC Investigators（2016）部分準確

資料來源 / Sources

• 〈白色強人II〉譁眾取寵 渲染暴力 抹黑精神復元人士 阻礙社區共融 / Big White Duel II: Sensationalism and Violence Smear People in Mental Health Recovery · 香港社區組織協會（SoCO） · 2022-08-26
• 《殘疾歧視條例》與精神病／前精神病患者（常見問題） / The Disability Discrimination Ordinance and People with a Mental Illness / Ex-mental Illness (FAQ) · 平等機會委員會（平機會）

相關頁面：影視橋段真偽、香港改編歌、大事記。